Revised Potter

After a lot of discussions and some excellent comments from a large number of people, I've gone back and significantly revised my Harry Potter reviews to make it clearer where I'm coming from in reviewing them and to tone down some of the vitriol while providing more actual information.

This is one of the nice things about maintaining reviews as web pages; if I happen to read one and see something that bothers me, I can fix it, and I can also improve reviews with insights that I get from discussion following their original posting. Normally, the changes are pretty minor and I won't bother to note them here, but in this case I did some significant rewriting, particularly of the first review.

If you're interested, you can read the new versions in their regular location (the review section of my home page), starting with The Sorcerer's Stone.

Posted: 2004-11-24 01:23 — Why no comments?

Hmm. Looks like comments are no longer displayed once an entry moves into the archives.

Guess I should have commented on your Potter reviews while they were still fresh. :-)

Posted by Dean Edmonds at 2004-12-04 23:23

Last spun 2022-02-06 from thread modified 2013-01-04