This page is no longer being updated. Please return to the Main Page and navigate
from there. If you got here by following one of my links, please email me to let me know I missed one.
Dave's Transformers Page
Transformers Comics
Reviews of comics adapting or related to TF movies
Last Updated 10/21/07
Link to Target exclusive prequel comic review added.
Transformers the Animated Movie: Bob Budiansky and Don Figueroa take a
stab at adapting the 1986 movie in four issues. The original comic
adaptation was in 3 issues, so that's some improvement.
Transformers the Animated Movie #1 (of 4): IDW - Oooh, glossy logo on
matte cover. Anyway, I've said many times that I think an adaptation of TV
or movie to comics really needs to use a full issue for every 8-10 minutes,
and almost no adaptation even comes close. This one is better than the
Marvel adaptation in that it spends 4 issues instead of 3 (of which I only
own #2, so I can't do a direct comparison yet), but still way too compressed.
Budiansky manages to keep most of the dialogue (although he left out "Such
heroic nonsense!") and Figueroa gamely tries to evoke lengthy action
sequences in a couple of panels here and there, but if you'd never seen the
movie, this comic would seem disjointed and rushed. Some of the dialogue
bits make less sense or carry less impact or even change their meaning
because we don't get to see the actions that go with them. There's also one
misdirected word balloon, but it's really a line anyone in the room could
have said without it being confusing. Well, anyone but Prime. As a trivia
aside, Ralph "not the Karate Kid" Macchio wrote Marvel's adaptation, so this
is not Budiansky directly recycling his own work. :) Mildly recommended.
$3.99 [Later note: okay, there's more than one mispointed word bubble, the
letterer seems to hate Perceptor.]
Transformers the Animated Movie #2 (of 4): IDW - From Prime's death to
Hot Rod landing in the drink on Quintessa. Fewer weird transition issues
than #1, although I'm slightly sad that the infamous "Spike curses" bit got
left out. I didn't notice any bad balloon placement, but there was at least
one footnote with no asterisked "source" panel, so it's still being edited
by, well not necessarily monkeys, but inattentive people. Looks nice,
though. Recommended. $3.99
Transformers the Animated Movie #3 (of 4): IDW - Goes from the
underwater sequence on Quintesson to the revival of Ultra Magnus on Junk. 22
pages of story (with page numbers), 10 pages of house ads. The compression
effects aren't so bad this time around, although there's a LOT of action
sequences in this part of the movie, and those tend to be easier to shorten
in the name of space. Recommended. $3.99
Transformers the Animated Movie #4 (of 4): IDW - While I didn't
fine-tooth-comb it for the kinds of errors that have plagued previous issues,
this one definitely had better pacing than those, and did a pretty good job
of conveying the climax. Granted, it manages this in part by skipping a LOT
of the time spent monkeying around in Unicron's guts. I do have a bit of a
quibble with the art, though...Figueroa does such a good job capturing the
cel feel of the a movie that the lettering and FX stand out like sore thumbs,
like cel fumetti or something. Recommended. $3.99
Transformers Official Movie Prequel - A four issue miniseries from IDW
telling a story set before the 2007 live action Transformers movie. Written
by Chris Ryall and Simon Furman, art by Don Figueroa.
Transformers Official Movie Prequel #1 (of 4): IDW - I got the
wraparound cover B. Don Figueroa almost makes the movie designs work, but
the drab sameness of them all (yes, they differ in a lot of little details,
but it all runs together) combiner with an obvious intent to NOT name the
viewpoint character makes it annoyingly hard to follow. Co-written by Ryall
and Furman, I'm guessing that it was Ryall who created the location
"Simfur". :) Anyway, both the art and writing are oppressively dark, murky
and obfuscated, and I really hope the movie doesn't continue with that tone
throughout. Mildly recommended. $3.99
"Primus Is A Cenobite?" Award to Transformers Official Movie Prequel #1
(of 4)
Transformers Official Movie Prequel #2 (of 4): IDW - I got cover A.
Mostly focuses on Megatron's arrival on Earth and subsequent fate, but has
some nice Victorian-era stuff as well. Still no idea who the protagonist of
#1 is, unless he was Optimus Prime in disguise. The action focuses mainly on
vehicle modes and humans, so the ugly movie designs aren't as much of a
factor, and Figueroa's art generally looks better than in #1. Recommended.
$3.99
"Fancy Meeting You Here, Skyfire" Award to Transformers Official Movie
Prequel #2 (of 4)
Transformers Official Movie Prequel #3 (of 4): IDW - Well, in case I
hadn't read the prequel novel to find out, the "A" cover of this one makes it
pretty clear that the unnamed Autobot in #1 was, indeed, Bumblebee. A
somewhat scattered issue that almost but not definitely contradicts the
prequel novel (and definitely contradicts the spirit of it). I do wonder how
they'll explain the gap between the events in 2003 and the movie in 2007,
though. Unless the movie is supposed to be set in 2003? Ah well. Mildly
recommended. $3.99
"Welcome To Tranquility" Award to Transformers Official Movie Prequel #3
(of 4)
Transformers Official Movie Prequel #4 (of 4): IDW - Well, as a prequel
it certainly can't have a significant resolution, but...eh. It was okay.
Starscream seems to have gotten the Standard Furman Grimlock Personality,
plus vocalisms, but with some of the classic Starscream snark. Good Figueroa
art, especially since he gets to work with mainly humans and vehicles rather
than vague piles of scrap. Mildly recommended. $3.99
"Mike Chary As A Transformer" Award to Transformers Official Movie
Prequel #4 (of 4)
Target Exclusive
Prequel: Link is to a review of the whole DVD package, but includes a few
paragraphs about the comic, and how it doesn't quite fit with Prequel #4
above. Nor, however, does Prequel #4 really work with the movie either.
Oops.
Transformers Official Movie Adaptation: A four issue series by Oprisko
and Milne. Released weekly in June 2007, although the TPB collecting all
four hit bookstores the first week of June, thus cutting comic shops off at
the knees. Oops.
Transformers Official Movie Adaptation #1 (of 4): IDW - Gasp! No variant
covers...well, other than retailer incentives. I guess the fact that this is
a weekly title made them decide to play it closer to the chest on the
variants this time. Plus, the regular cover is wraparound. Fair warning
going in, I've already read the official novel, the junior novelization and
several kiddiebook adaptations by this point, so I may unconsciously fill in
any gaps in the storytelling. On the other hand, I may unfairly compare it
to those other adaptations as well. Keep in mind my rule of thumb, a good
comic adaptation really needs one 22-page issue for every 10-15 minutes of
screen time, which puts this one a few issues shy of the mark, even with 26
pages per issue. The compression shows, an entire plot thread is essentially
dropped, and most scenes are rushed. It's not horrible, but it really
could've used a few more issues. Also has Blackout and Frenzy mini-posters,
and an interview with one of the producers. Milne does a decent job of
retaining the detail of the movie designs without the detail making the art
impossible to follow. Mildly recommended. $3.99
"Needs More Maggie" Award to Transformers the Official Movie Adaptation
#1 (of 4)
Transformers Official Movie Adaptation #2 (of 4): IDW - You know, I've
seen these scenes enough times in other adaptations that any new presentation
has to be really good to impress me. And this ain't. Too compressed, and
while Milne generally manages to make sense of the storytelling with his art,
some panels simply look bad. Has another pull out poster, a Barricade pinup,
pictures of Deluxe Brawl and an interview with the writer of the comic. Very
mildly recommended. $3.99
"HUGZ!" Award to Transformers Official Movie Adaptation #2 (of 4
Transformers Official Movie Adaptation #3 (of 4): IDW - Most of this
issue's events take place at night, with associated dark and murky colors on
way too many pages. The cover art looks rushed, and the story inside is
mediocre in terms of adapting the full story. Very mildly recommended.
$3.99
"Okay, Maggie's IN It, If Barely" Award to Transformers Official Movie
Adaptation #3 (of 4)
Transformers Official Movie Adaptation #4 (of 4): IDW - This opens with
a background element that always annoys me, the statement that all advanced
real world tech is reverse-engineered from some alien artifact. An artifact
in the hands of only one government. As if all new tech of the past century
has come solely from America. Pfeh. If they had some stuff more advanced
than real life tech (as used in the Ghosts of Yesterday prequel novel),
that'd work. But while it worked as a laugh in Men In Black, it's just dumb
in a story trying to be taken seriously. That aside, this is another muddled
mess with insufficient pagecount to really adapt the story, and it jumps from
scene to scene in such a way that if I hadn't already read the novel, I'd
have no idea what was going on half the time. Pass on this adaptation and
just watch the movie or read the novel. Neutral. $3.99
"Speed Dial's Psycho Ex" Award to Transformers Official Movie Adaptation
#4 (of 4)